Another Attempt By the State to Shield Forensics From Cross-Examination

Another case to be heard by the US Supreme Court where the State doesn’t want their foren­sic sci­ence evi­dence ques­tioned by the defense.

ON Tuesday, the Supreme Court will hear oral argu­ments in Williams v. Illinois, the lat­est in a string of cases address­ing whether the Sixth Amendment’s con­fronta­tion clause — which gives the accused in a

[Continue Reading Another Attempt By the State to Shield Forensics From Cross-Examination…]

Share

No Forensic Science Exemption to US Constitution

In a 5–4 non-partisan rul­ing, the United States Supreme Court fur­ther clar­i­fied the defendant’s right to con­front their accuser in criminal cases.

Where Melendez-Diaz ruled the pros­e­cu­tion could not sim­ply sub­mit a crime lab­o­ra­tory report as evi­dence, June 23, 2011’s rul­ing in Bullcoming v. New Mexico fur­ther explains the courts deci­sion to uphold the rights of the accused,

[Continue Reading No Forensic Science Exemption to US Constitution…]

Share

Melendez-Diaz Under Attack by Prosecutors

Apparently pros­e­cu­tors don’t like crim­i­nal defense attor­neys to cross-examine foren­sic sci­en­tists. They’d rather just have a piece of paper in court that can’t be cross-examined. To that goal the recent Melendez-Diaz deci­sion is up for review.

Prosecutors hope that the new Justice Sotomayor (an ex-prosecutor her­self) will side with them, throw due process out the window

[Continue Reading Melendez-Diaz Under Attack by Prosecutors…]

Share

Laboratory Analyst Falsifies Lab Report

A foren­sic lab­o­ra­tory ana­lyst dry-labs cases. That is, they didn’t actu­ally per­form the foren­sic test­ing they are sup­posed to, and instead just sim­ply authors reports that indi­cate a crime has occurred.

A for­mer chemist with Erie County’s crime lab­o­ra­tory admit­ted she failed to con­duct the proper foren­sic tests in a local drug case, but authorities

[Continue Reading Laboratory Analyst Falsifies Lab Report…]

Share

Creative Solution For Melendez-Diaz Testimony Complaints

If Arkansas can come up with a sim­ple way to allow ana­lysts to tes­tify with­out seri­ously effect­ing their abil­ity to con­tinue their lab­o­ra­tory duties, why all the hand-wringing and whin­ing in other states?

The link allows exam­in­ers at the crime lab to tes­tify with­out leav­ing their office.

“I’m very pleased with it and I’ve encour­aged the pros­e­cu­tors and

[Continue Reading Creative Solution For Melendez-Diaz Testimony Complaints…]

Share